SIX COMMON ESTATE PLANNING MISTAKES. . . AND THE CELEBRITIES WHO MADE THEM
INTRODUCTION
Financial professionals give their clients lots of advice related to estate planning. Much of that advice centers around the proper transfer of assets at death.
Unfortunately, clients make plenty of mistakes when putting together their estate plans, including:
- Waiting to make plans until it’s too late
- Failing to work with a professional team
- Making inadequate transition plans for the family business
- Failing to manage estate taxes
- Letting documents get out of date
- Forgetting to plan for the possibility of incapacity
An estate planning attorney can help the client navigate past these mistakes. However, the financial and life insurance professionals also play key roles in making sure the client’s estate planning is effective.
What if the critical issues haven’t been addressed?
Unfortunately, there are plenty of horror stories involving famous people who made these estate planning mistakes. We have included several examples.
These anecdotes help to illustrate the importance of doing proper planning. Because clients may know some of the situations described, the information may aid in understanding why some mistakes can lead to disastrous consequences.
THE MISTAKES AND THE STORIES
Waiting Until It’s Too Late—Prince
The musical artist Prince died at his home in suburban Minneapolis of an accidental opioid overdose on April 21, 2016. He was 57.
Five days after Prince’s death, his sister Tyka filed a petition in Carver County, Minnesota, asking the probate court to appoint Bremer Trust special administrator of Prince’s estate. In her petition, Tyka asserted that:
- Prince left no last will, and
- Prince’s closest heirs were his sister and five living half-siblings.
Under the Minnesota law of intestacy, a person who dies without a will and has
- no living spouse,
- no children, and
- no living parents
leaves their estate assets to their siblings (including half-siblings).
After the court petition was filed, hundreds of people reportedly began the process of checking whether they might be another half-sibling of Prince. The probate court was called on to help evaluate the claims of at least half a dozen of those. The court ultimately recognized only the siblings identified in Tyka’s petition.
Prince left real estate, business interests, and intellectual property worth many millions of dollars. Since he had prepared no estate planning documents prior to his death, the probate court had to sort out how to deal with those assets.
If Prince had at least a will document, it would have helped eliminate some of the issues raised in the probate process. For example, Prince’s family connections were complicated, so the process of determining kinship was difficult, time-consuming, and expensive to sort out. Clear words in a will document could have bypassed many of the heirship issues that arose during the administration of Prince’s estate.
Here are a few other examples of famous people who waited until it was too late:
- Sonny Bono died in a tragic skiing accident in 1998, leaving his third wife and children from multiple relationships. He apparently failed to have any kind of will or estate plan.
- Steve McNair, the former Tennessee Titan quarterback and league MVP, was killed in 2009 without having made a written plan for his wife or children from a prior relationship.
- Howard Hughes passed away at age 70 with an estate worth about $2.5 billion. Despite a court-rejected claim to the contrary by Melvin Dummar (memorialized by the 1980 film Melvin and Howard), Hughes died without a valid will. Hughes’s estate was distributed to his cousins.
Failing to Work with a Professional Team—Aretha Franklin
According to probate documents filed in Michigan, in the years before her death, Aretha Franklin apparently tried to draft her own will documents. Unfortunately for her children and other potential heirs, the handwritten pages left many important questions unanswered.
Aretha Franklin died on August 16, 2018. In May of the following year, Aretha’s niece, Sabrina Owens, filed a probate petition in Michigan. The petition said that as of the date of her death, Aretha Franklin had apparently left three handwritten documents that were intended, in part, to be directions regarding who should inherit her property.
All of the Franklin heirs were shown the documents but were apparently unable to agree on what they meant or how they should be applied to the Franklin estate. Sabrina and her lawyers were not able to independently determine the validity and effect of the documents either—so they asked the probate court to do it.
Michigan, the state of Franklin’s domicile at the time of her death, recognizes the validity of handwritten wills. That said, the probate court was asked to sort out the following three documents:
- Aretha Franklin’s handwritten note dated October 20, 2010, according to the probate court petition, was found inside a locked cabinet. This note’s apparent purpose was to explicitly revoke any prior will documents completed or signed by Ms. Franklin.
- Aretha Franklin’s handwritten will dated June 21, 2010, was apparently found inside the same locked cabinet as the October 20, 2010, note. It had the most detailed testamentary instructions of the three documents.
- The personal representative said Aretha Franklin’s handwritten will dated March 31, 2014, was found beneath a couch cushion. It also had detailed testamentary provisions.
The documents had inconsistent provisions between them and they were clearly drafted by a non-lawyer. The probate court was first asked to decide which of the handwritten wills would be considered the legal reflection of Franklin’s final wishes. After a jury trial, it was determined that her 2014 document was Franklin’s last will.
What mistake was made? Aretha Franklin decided, for her own reasons, to create a will by herself—without using an attorney to draft one. In part because of that decision, her family spent significant avoidable time and money in probate court figuring out her testamentary wishes.
Here are two other examples of famous people who waited until it was too late:
- Charles Kuralt was a fixture on CBS television news for many years. Kuralt died in 1997, leaving a will passing his estate to his wife and two daughters. However, Kuralt had a longtime secret companion at the time of his death. Shortly before his death, Kuralt wrote his companion a letter expressing the intention to leave his 90-acre parcel of Montana property to her.
Kuralt did not get around to having a lawyer formalize his intention prior to his death. When Kuralt’s widow started the probate process, the details about the secret relationship came out, causing embarrassment, delay, and unnecessary expenses to the process.
See https://www.cbsnews.com/news/kuralts-mistress-gets-house.
- Supreme Court Justice Warren Burger passed away in 1995, having prepared a short will on his own. His will document was not a masterpiece of jurisprudence. It had many misspellings and apparently omitted giving his executor the kind of powers standard in a will prepared by an experienced estate planning attorney. The pieces missing from the do-it-yourself document apparently cost his estate tens of thousands of dollars.
See https://www.deseret.com/1995/11/1/19201991/ex-chief-justice-had-legal-flaw-his-will.
Failing to Create a Plan for Business Continuation That Preserved Family Harmony
Dr. Jerry Buss was instrumental in making the Los Angeles Lakers NBA franchise a perennial powerhouse in the league. Buss originally purchased the Lakers in 1979. The Lakers were very successful under Buss’s ownership, winning ten NBA championships with such players as Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Magic Johnson, James Worthy, Shaquille O’Neal, Kobe Bryant, and Pau Gasol, and with coaches Pat Riley and Phil Jackson.
Buss inspired the Lakers’ Showtime era with his vision that basketball games must be entertaining. His contributions to basketball were recognized by his induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame in 2010.
Jerry Buss made detailed plans for the continuation of the Lakers organization in the hands of his children after his death. However, when he passed in 2013, the transition was anything but smooth.
Prior to his death, Buss made plans to transfer control and his ownership stake in the Lakers in equal shares to his six children. As reported by ESPN in 2013:
The plan, which was put in place years ago by Buss, calls for his daughter, Jeanie, to become the Lakers’ governor and represent the team at the NBA board of governors meetings. She will also handle the business operations of the team.
Buss’s son, Jim, will handle basketball operations of the team.
Unfortunately for the Buss children, the management of the Lakers franchise became complicated and contentious. Beginning just prior to Jerry Buss’s death and continuing thereafter, the Lakers began to suffer from disappointing seasons. As a result, Jeanie ended up firing Jim in 2017.
Later that year Jeanie went to Los Angeles County Superior Court, seeking a restraining order against her brothers Jim and Johnny to prevent them from pursuing an alleged plan to upend the Lakers’ board of directors and her role in it. That court action was ultimately resolved by adding two other Buss children to the group overseeing the family ownership of the Lakers.
However, recently Jeanie has asked the California court to stop her siblings from pursuing a sale of the Lakers franchise. See https://www.espn.com/nba/story/_/id/49736217/jeanie-buss-asks-court-block-siblings-vote-sell-lakers-shares.
Even though the saga of the Lakers and the Buss family is unique, it does reinforce the idea that successful family business continuation planning is hard. Very hard. There are so many potential issues that need to be deftly handled—during the planning process and after—to achieve a good result.
What specifically did Dr. Buss need to do to avoid the family drama over franchise management after his death? It’s hard to say. In any event, the flaws in the Lakers transition in family ownership may offer lessons to those seeking to make continuation plans in somewhat similar circumstances.
Failing to Anticipate and Manage Estate Taxes—Joe Robbie
In November 1989, Joe Robbie was the owner of the Miami Dolphins and the football stadium that bore his name. He was motivated to make plans to keep the Dolphins in the Robbie family. He established a trust and funded it with two partnership interests that together held an 88 percent stake in the Dolphins.
Robbie died in early 1990, with an estate worth more than $100 million. According to court documents, most of Robbie’s estate was earmarked to pass to his surviving spouse Elizabeth in a QTIP-type trust. If that came about, and if proper tax elections were made, the biggest portion of any estate tax would have been deferred until Elizabeth’s death.
After his death, just three of Robbie’s nine children—Janet, Tim, and Dan—became trustees of the trust. Robbie was also survived by his wife Elizabeth, who was also the mother of his children.
Robbie and his family also owned Miami Sports Corp. That company at the time of Joe’s death owned the remaining 12 percent of the Dolphins and 100 percent of the stadium. Janet, Tim, and Dan were named to Miami Sports’s advisory board along with two nonfamily members.
After their father’s death, the trustees negotiated to sell part of the team and the stadium to Wayne Huizenga, the then-CEO of Blockbuster. Joe Robbie had earlier discussed with him a partial sale to help pay down $90 million in construction debt, but talks had broken off.
Dan, Tim, and Janet negotiated a deal under which Huizenga would buy 50 percent of the stadium and 15 percent of the Dolphins. The rest of the family argued against consummating the deal just a few months after the elder Robbie’s death. However, the trustees went ahead with the deal. Huizenga paid $12 million for the Dolphins stake and $5 million for half the stadium.
To compound the family friction, just six months after their father’s death, Tim, Dan, and Janet dismissed their older brother from his post as Dolphins executive vice president. Their mother was apparently incensed.
A few months later Elizabeth Robbie moved to protect her own interests in Joe’s estate. Rather than accepting a QTIP trust under the control of Janet, Tim, and Dan, Elizabeth elected to claim 30 percent of her husband’s $70 million estate. She was entitled to this choice under Florida law.
While the 30 percent estate share claimed by Elizabeth was entitled to the unlimited marital estate tax deduction, the other $50 million of the probate estate was not. That meant an additional—and unexpected—estate tax liability of about $25 million. To raise the money, the trustees were forced to sell additional interests in the stadium and Dolphins to Huizenga.
What are the lessons from the Robbie estate?
In this situation, the possibility of estate taxes was not properly planned for. Even though most of the estate was designed to qualify for the unlimited marital deduction, circumstances accelerated the bill. Since there was inadequate liquidity in the estate to cover the taxes, the team and the stadium had to be sold.
Letting Documents Get Out of Date—Heath Ledger
Heath Ledger was a highly successful young actor, with critically acclaimed roles in Brokeback Mountain, A Knight’s Tale, and The Dark Knight. He died of an apparent accidental overdose of prescription medicine in 2008. He was 28 years old.
Ledger left a will from 2003 leaving his estate to his parents and siblings. Subsequent to the execution of that will, daughter Matilda Rose was born in 2005 to Ledger and partner Michelle Williams.
After Ledger’s death, the Williams family hired attorneys to keep Matilda Rose from being excluded from her father’s estate. In the early stages of the settlement of Ledger’s estate, it seemed as if litigation would be inevitable. However, from the beginning, Ledger’s father Kim maintained that Heath’s daughter would be the primary beneficiary of the estate.
In 2008, Kim told a reporter that the family had agreed to leave Ledger’s $16.3 million fortune to Matilda.
Did Heath Ledger intend for his daughter to inherit all his estate? Did he intend to leave a bequest directly for his child’s mother, Michelle Williams? What kind of trust provisions did he have in mind for Matilda Rose’s benefit? We’ll never know.
Neglecting to Plan for the Possibility of Incapacity—Casey Kasem
Kemal Amin “Casey” Kasem was a radio presenter who created and hosted several radio countdown programs, notably American Top 40. He was also a voice actor, perhaps most famously voicing the character of Shaggy in the animated franchise Scooby Doo.
In 2007, Kasem was treated for Parkinson’s-like symptoms which were later diagnosed as Lewy body dementia. Kasem’s condition worsened over time. His wife Jean acted as caregiver, and Kasem’s children from his first marriage complained that Jean was preventing them from seeing their father.
The older Kasem children sought a conservatorship over their father’s care in 2013, and their initial petition was denied. Later in 2014, Jean removed Casey from his nursing home, and subsequently Kasem’s daughter Kerri renewed her petition and was granted temporary conservatorship.
The family court fight over the details of Casey’s care continued until his death in June 2014. After his death, the children and Jean continued to argue over the disposition of his remains until Kasem’s body was buried in December.
The drama did not end there. In November 2015, three of Kasem’s children and his brother sued his widow for wrongful death. The lawsuit charged Jean Kasem with elder abuse and inflicting emotional distress on the children by restricting access before his death. A police investigation found that he had received appropriate medical care and that there was no evidence pointing to homicide. The suits were settled in 2019.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casey_Kasem.
Perhaps if Kasem had prepared robust health care proxies prior to his death, the family discord surrounding his final year could have been avoided.
CONCLUSION
We are reminded constantly that famous people are not always good role models. The news is filled with stories about how many make bad choices with regard to relationships, money, and lifestyle.
Unfortunately, celebrities also make tragic mistakes with regard to their estate planning. For many, because of great wealth and complex family relationships, the consequences of failing to plan are dire.
The famous people described in this newsletter each failed in some aspect of their estate planning. The failures resulted in lost businesses, lost wealth, unexpected distributions of estates and failures to fully protect family members. Perhaps the clients of financial professionals can learn from celebrities’ example to avoid similar mistakes in their own situations.